Top 7 Best Fly Tying Kit

Once you try your hand at fly fishing, you will get hooked and sooner or later you will want to tie your own flies. It goes with saying that fly tying is cheaper than spending your money on buying flies. Also, the quality and patterns of store-bought flies may not be the best. So, fly tying is the best option and it a satisfying one.

 

However, as a novice fly fisherman, it can be confusing to tie flies. Thankfully, you can depend on the best fly tying kit to help you. Such a kit has the right tools. It is prudent to realize that each fly tying tool is designed to meet the needs of a fly fisherman, the type of fish they want to catch and the places where they want to fish. Knowing this will enable you to figure out the kind of flies that are apt for you and the best fly tying kit to help you tie them.

Best Overall Fly Tying Tool

Dr Slick Fly Tying Tools Kit

5/5
  • Compact with a carry case
  • High-quality tools
  • Number of tools for tying flies
  • Vise clamp is adjustable based on different hooks

We realize that with so many different fly tying tools, it can be confusing to choose one. That is why we have reviewed 7 of the best fly tying kits. Once you know these, you do your own research to shortlist one kit that is ideal for you. You can rest assured knowing that our reviews are completely unbiased and based on information from other users and our personal experience. Our reviews are designed to help you understand the pros and cons of each kit so that you make an informed fly tying kit purchase decision.

Table: Top 7 Best Fly Tying Kits

S.No Product Name Rating Pricing
1. 71ofmdS7n0L._AC_SL1200_ Dr Slick Fly Tying Tools Kit [4.6/5.0] Check-button-1.png
2. 719DggXj9NL._AC_SL1001_ XFishman Fly Tying Tool Kit [4.5/5.0] Check-button-1.png
3. 61-YkL7D0rL._AC_SL1000_ DDF Beginner Fly Tying Kit for Saltwater [4.3/5.0] Check-button-1.png
4. 81zoTFrlMXL._AC_SL1500_ S.F. Products Standard Fly Tying Tool Kit [4.1/5.0] Check-button-1.png
5. 91JqgNkr5iL._AC_SL1500_ Scientific Anglers Deluxe Fly Tying Kit [3.9/5.0] Check-button-1.png
6. 812yvfWpezL._AC_SL1500_ Colorado Anglers Z797 Wooden Fly Tying Kit [3.8/5.0] Check-button-1.png
7. 91JGastN0BL._AC_SL1500_ WetFly Deluxe Fly Tying Kit [3.8/5.0] Check-button-1.png

#1. Dr Slick Fly Tying Tools Kit

This compact kit makes it to the top of the best fly tying kit list as it comes with numerous tools that you need for making your own flies. It has a carry case that lets you carry the tools in a safe manner whenever you go fishing.

5/5

Pros

  • A smart gift for novice fly fishers
  • Compact
  • Has a range of tools
  • Vise clamp can be adjusted for different hooks
  • Tools are durable and high-quality

Cons

  • The bobbin can be a little unsteady and shaky
  • Have to buy the thread, feathers, dubbing, and furs separately
  • Does not have a vice

Product Specifications

  • Bobbin
  • Scissors
  • Hackle pliers
  • Threader
  • Hair stacker

The scissors are sharp and can easily cut hair from a gnat’s back!

Why We Recommend This Product

Dr Slick Fly Tying Tools will help you learn how to tie your flies in different ways and patterns. In case you are new to fly fishing, this is the tool kit that you need at your side to learn fly tying. It will hone your skills. The tools included in the kit are durable and long-lasting; they are made from brass and stainless steel. You never have to worry about the tools rusting or giving in to corrosion.

 

The kit has straight scissors, ceramic bobbin, brass dubbin needle, brass bobbin threader, brass hackle pliers, brass whip finisher, and brass hair stacker. The large carry case had die-cut foam that allows you to carry the tools without them getting damaged. The tools have a polished appearance, and the kit is reasonably priced considering the quality.

While the tools appear solid, they can break if not handled with care. So, do not be rough while handling Dr Slick Fly Tying Tools Kit.

#2. XFishman Fly Tying Tool Kit

XFishman Fly Tying Tool Kit can be used with ease by beginners and intermediates. It comes with seven basic fly tying tools that are encased in a retro tool bag that looks quite elegant. You can place up to 12 different tools in the bag, which is designed to keep the tools organized and safe from damage.

4.8/5

Pros

  • Affordably priced
  • Comes with two bobbins
  • Has seven fly tying tools
  • Can be used with all types of fly tying threads

Cons

  • Hackle pliers can be a little stiff
  • Scissors can be a little blunt in some kits
  • Does not come with a vise

Product Specifications

  • Scissors
  • Bobbins
  • Hackle pliers
  • Rotary whip finishers
  • Bobbin threader and cleaner

The two bobbins can be used for relacing the threads in a continuous manner

Why We Recommend This Product

We like the compact feel of this fly tying tool kit. It has essential tools that allow you to tie flies and snare the fish. We loved the fact that this tool kit comes with two bobbins. It makes relacing the threads quick and simple process. The two bobbins can be used with all types of fly fishing threads regardless of the size of the spool. Even the two different sized rotary whip finishers were a welcome surprise.

 

The travel bag is actually a pouch made from PV leathered material. It is supposed to be waterproof, but we did not test it. The pouch can accommodate up to 12 tools and can be rolled for easy transport. The tools are durable, made from steel and brass. So, expect them to be long-lasting.

You can polish the tools with paper towels and they will get a nice shine.

#3. DDF Beginner Fly Tying Kit for Saltwater

Most fly tying kits that you get out there are for freshwater fly fishing, so it was like a breath of fresh air to get a fly tying kit that can be used in saltwater. This is the perfect kit for catching trout, panfish, and bass. The kit has everything you need to tie flies and enjoy success during your fishing trip.

4.7/5

Pros

  • Items come labeled and state their name and use
  • Ideal for beginners
  • Can be used in saltwater
  • Has fly fishing materials
  • High-quality scissors
  • Solid vise capable of holding hooks
  • The kit comes with fly pattern cards

Cons

  • Not the ideal choice for experienced fly fishers
  • Tools will have to be replaced over a period of time

Product Specifications

  • AA vise
  • Assorted hooks
  • Thread
  • Floss
  • Marabou
  • Yarns
  • Bodkin
  • Scissors
  • Rotating whip finisher
  • Bobbin

Kit contains sufficient materials and a starting point to tie flies without any hassles.

Why We Recommend This Product

The DDF Beginner Fly Tying Kit for Saltwater has a wide range of materials, like furs, feathers, chenille, yarn, marabou, flash and thread, and all items come labeled and with suggested use. While you may not find materials in this kit to tie every type of fly, there is sufficient material to make most types of flies that are ubiquitously used.

 

We were impressed with the scissors as it was better than we expected. The vise too is strong and has the ability to hold hooks with ease. It also comes with 50 hooks which are sufficient for beginners, but they may end up ordering more in a few days or weeks. The kit has pattern cards that allow beginners to follow and create their own flies.

Good quality beginner fly tying kit, but you will need to buy the head cement.

#4. S.F. Products Standard Fly Tying Tool Kit

The S.F. Products Standard Fly Tying Tool Kit comes with the basic tools that you would require to tie flies. You can get all the tools in a wooden case, making it easy and convenient to carry the tools for your next fly fishing expedition.

4.6/5

Pros

  • Affordably priced
  • Comes with an instructional DVD
  • Ideal for beginners but can be used by seasoned fishers as well
  • Durable and easy to use tools

Cons

  • Instructional DVD is not comprehensive
  • Some fishers may find the tools small

Product Specifications

  • AA vise
  • Dubbing twister
  • Scissors
  • Whip finisher
  • Bodkin
  • Standard bobbin
  • Bobbin threader
  • Hackle pliers
  • Pedestal base

You cannot remove the vise base from the carry case.

Why We Recommend this Product

On using the tools, we did find them a little small, but that could be due to the size of our hands! Nonetheless, we found the tools easy to use. We really like that we could carry the tools with us for fly fishing without causing any damage to them. So, it gets a thumbs up from us for the wooden case.

 

The tools are made from steel and brass, so they are long-lasting and not prone to rusting and corrosion. We also found that the scissors were quite sharp. What we didn’t like is that the vise base cannot be removed from the carry case. Other than this, we loved this fly tying kit.

You can continue using the tools even if you graduate to another vise later on.

#5. Scientific Anglers Deluxe Fly Tying Kit

The Scientific Anglers Deluxe Fly Tying Kit is made from high-quality materials. It is one of the best starter kits for anyone who is keen about learning fly tying. This kit comprises not just tools and hooks, but also fly tying materials which are safely enclosed in a travel case. It also has a DVD that introduces beginners to the basics of fly tying.

4.8/5

Pros

  • The vise comes with an angled head and a C-clamp base
  • Lightweight and portable
  • Comes with fly tying materials
  • Can be used for making dry flies, wet flies, and streamers

Cons

  • The vise may have quality issues
  • Does not have a whip finish tool

Product Specifications

  • Fly tying vise
  • Bobbin
  • Threader
  • Bodkin
  • Hackle pliers
  • Scissors
  • Hooks
  • Fly tying materials
  • Instructional DVD

Can be used for making different patterns, including streamers, nymphs, dry flies and wet flies.

Why We Recommend this Product

It is one of the best fly tying kits for starters. It is affordable and the quality of the tools is quite reasonable considering the price. It is ideal for tying pheasant tails, but you may feel short-changed when you attempt wooly buggers.

 

We liked the case and the clasps. It enables you to carry the tools in an organized manner. The tools are pretty durable. We found that the kit was quite addictive as we could not stop tying flies even though we hadn’t planned a fishing trip!

#6. Colorado Anglers Z797 Wooden Fly Tying Kit

This is the perfect kit for fly fishermen to show off and demonstrate their prowess in fly tying. Although the case is made from wood, it is long-lasting and works well to keep the fly tying tools safe. Usually, this is kit is considered ideal for beginners, but we believe that the tools are the right choice for experienced fly fishers.  

4.5/5

Pros

  • Reasonably priced
  • Can be used by beginners and seasoned fly fishers
  • Has all the essential fly tying tools
  • Easy to carry and store

Cons

  • Case not waterproof
  • Fly tying materials have to be bought separately
  • The instruction manual is not comprehensive

Product Specifications

  • A wooden case to carry the tools
  • Vise
  • Bobbin
  • Threader
  • Bodkin
  • Dubbing twister
  • Scissors
  • Whip finisher
  • Hackle pliers

This fly tying kit is the best choice for tying bucktails of varying sizes.

Why We Recommend this Product

You may have doubts about the carry case as it is made from wood. However, you can rest assured that the case is sturdy and long-lasting, and it will keep your fly tying tools safe and secure. It has a built-in base, making it ideal for tight spaces.

 

The tools are quite easy to use and they are made from steel, so you can be assured that they are sturdy. It enables you to tie more than 500 flies in a span of one month. The tools are sized just right, making them rather easy to work with. We really like the vise, as it was easy to work with.

It does not come with furs and fly tying materials as they need to be purchased separately.

#7. WetFly Deluxe Fly Tying Kit

The WetFly Deluxe Fly Tying Kit is the perfect choice for beginner and intermediate fly fishers. It comes with the necessary tools that you require to tie flies. The materials are quite high-quality, and as a beginner, you will find it easy to use the tools. The instructional DVD and book are the perfect visual aid for newbies.

4.6/5

Pros

  • Quality tools for beginners and intermediates
  • Reasonably priced fly tying kit
  • Has all the necessary tools for tying flies
  • Comes with instructional DVD and book
  • Comes with a carry case

Cons

  • You will need to add to your collection of tools over time
  • Not the best choice for experienced fly fishermen

Product Specifications

  • Sizes 8,12 and 14 hooks
  • Scissors
  • Hackle pliers
  • Bobbin
  • Bobbin threader
  • Hair stacker
  • Fine copper wire
  • Black thread
  • Vise
  • Poly yarn
  • Instructional DVD and book

The kit has materials, such as chenille, hackle, and dubbing, for making a variety of ties (48 to be precise)

Why We Recommend This Product

If you learn to tie your own flies, you will save money and that is exactly what the WetFly Deluxe Fly Tying Kit teaches you. It is perfect for beginner and intermediate fly fishermen, and you will find that the kit has all the essential tools, like vise, hackle pliers and scissors.

 

We found that the tools are of quite good quality considering the price and we liked the fact that the kit comes with a book and instructional DVD to help newbies hone their fly tying skills. The kit has over 20 items, making it a worthwhile investment.

You can use the kit to make small bucktails on treble hooks without any problem.

Tips for Buying the Best Fly Tying Kit

When you are looking for the best fly tying kit, take a closer look at the individual tools that come in the kit. Whether you are a beginner who is just starting out or you want to replace the basic tools in your fly tying kit, these are the eight essential tools that the fly tying kit should have.

 

Vise: You will need a vise to help you tie the flies. You can do without one if you already know how to go about tying flies. Remember, hooks are quite small and a good quality vice will make it easy to manage and hold the hooks. Make sure that the vise can be adjusted to accommodate different sized hooks. It should be made from durable materials. A C-clamp vise is a better option than a pedestal vise.

 

Bobbin Holder and Bobbin Wire Loop: A bobbin holder makes it easy to tie the fly. It ensures you reduce wastage of the thread, enhance the tension and do not lose feathers and furs during the tying process. Most bobbins are made from ceramic, brass or plastic. While a bobbin wire loop is not a necessity, it does help make the entire process of threading a quick one.

 

Scissors: A fly tying kit without scissors is incomplete. Make sure that the scissors are sharp and have a fine point that enables you to cut close.

 

Hackle Pliers: This tool is designed to make it easy to wrap the hackle around the hook. It holds on to the hackle so that there is no risk of it slipping during the wrapping process.

 

Whip Finish Tool: It is quite possible to whip finish ties using the fingers. However, if you use the whip finish tool, it makes the entire process accurate, quick and easy. What more could you ask for?

 

Dubbin Needle: It is also known as Bodkin and you need to apply the head cement, comb the underfur, divide the tips of the wing, free any hackle fibers that are trapped and for teasing the dubbed material.

 

Dubbing Twister: A dubbing twister is designed to create tension and hold the fur in place. As a result, it lets you twist the thread and dubbing into a rope so that you can make dubbing loops.

 

Threader: In case your eyesight is not what it used to be, you will find the threader a blessing. It enables intricate movements and helps to save you time.

 

Hair Stacker: This tool allows you to position all the fibers so that you can go ahead and finish tying them.

 

These items are basic essentials that a good fly tying tool kit should have. Besides these basic tools, it will be an added bonus if your fly tying tool kit also has small pliers and tweezers. They can prove to be quite useful.

 

The Final Verdict

After testing these seven fly tying kits and reading user reviews, we believe that the Dr Slick Fly Tying Tools Kit deserves to be called the best fly tying kit in the market. It comes with all the basic tools that every kit should have and then some more. It is compact that makes it easy to carry the tools during fishing trips. The vise clamp allows you to adjust the vise to accommodate different hook sizes with relative ease. The tools are top-quality, durable and easy to use.

You might also be intersted in: 

Leave a Comment